প্রকাশ: 17/12/2022
Bangladesh
has completed 51 years of victory. In Bangladesh, Victory Day means joy and
celebration. Throughout December, the country is full of festivities. But this
time it was different. Political tension dampened our victory celebrations to
some extent. BNP held a mass rally in Dhaka due to various incidents. Six out
of seven BNP MPs have already resigned. The Election Commission has announced
by-elections in vacant seats. On the other hand, BNP announced a 10-point demand
from the Golapbag rally on December 10. The party has also announced to hold a
simultaneous movement to realize the 10-point demand. On December 13, a protest
march was held on the 10-point demand. Meanwhile, Awami League is going to hold
its national council on December 24. On that day, BNP gave the program of mass
rally. How did BNP give this program on the day of the country's main political
party’s national council? Later, however, BNP changed the date of their rally.
But the secret intention of BNP has come out. The party, which has been out of
power for 16 years, wants to create a violent and chaotic situation. The
question is - why do you have to clash, set fire, and throw dead bodies to get
to power? Does that mean that the intension of BNP is not to go to power but to
bring someone else to power? Has BNP become a mercenary political party? A political
party that works for the implementation of other's plans. Not only the
announcement of the date of mass rally on 24th December, but one of the
opposition political parties in the country has been behaving intolerant for
some days. A kind of instability is being observed among BNP leaders. The mass
rally on Dhaka for example. BNP said it will hold a rally in Nayapaltan. Dhaka
Metropolitan Police Commissioner gave permission to hold the rally in Suhrawardy
Udyan. Suhrawardy Udyan is the best place to hold rally in Dhaka city. Awami
League, BNP and many other political parties has hold many rallies here. But it
was not understood why BNP suddenly took a stand against it. What BNP did in
Golapbagh on December 10, could have been done in Suhrawardy Udyan. So why try
to create so much tension about December 10? Why BNP leaders and workers
started gathering in Nayapaltan from December 7? What did BNP want to do with
160 sacks of rice and huge amount of water? In the end, BNP could not hold a
rally in Nayapaltan. The conversation between BNP General Secretary Mirza
Fakhrul Islam Alamgir and police officer Biplab Kumar Sarkar on December 7 is viral
on social media. BNP Secretary General made all efforts to make the police
officer lose patience. But Biplab handled the situation with great patience,
tolerance and modesty. After the December 7 incident, some important leaders
including BNP General Secretary Mirza Fakhrul Islam Alamgir, Mirza Abbas, Ruhul
Kabir Rizvi were arrested. As a result, the BNP retreated and eventually held
its rally at an alternative venue. It has been proved that neither the
government nor the law enforcement agency wanted to prevent the BNP rally. They
just wanted to ensure that there is no riot or violence in the name of rally. But
what did the BNP want to achieve by rallying in Nayapaltan?
The
biggest surprise in this rally was the announcement of resignation of seven
parliament members of BNP. On December 11, six MPs submitted their resignations
to the Speaker. The current parliament has a term of only one year. During this
period, only seven members of Parliament resigned and what message did they
actually give? After the 2018 elections, BNP first said that they do not accept
this parliament. They will not take oath as members of Parliament. But after
that, the members of parliament of BNP took oath one by one (Except only Mirza
Fakhrul Islam Alamgir). BNP also nominated Rumin Farhana for women quota. Apart
from giving some stormy speeches in Parliament, BNP MPs had no role to play.
There is a big difference between field politics and parliamentary politics.
Sudhanshu Sheikh Halder,
Suranjit Sengupta, Shah Aziz, Mizanur Rahman Chowdhury, Barrister Maudud Ahmed,
Tofail Ahmed were bright stars in the National Parliament. They knew the rules
of procedure, they knew the law, they were deeply studied about parliamentary
customs. A Member of
Parliament does not fulfill his duties by shouting abuse like Rumin Farhana or Harun-ar-Rashid.
Needs depth, needs erudition. In my opinion, Jatiya Party's Kazi Feroze Rashid,
Mujibul Haque Chunnu, Pir Misbah are much more mature and have played a
responsible role according to the parliamentary norms than the loud shouts of BNP
MPs. Therefore, I do not think that the resignation of BNP MPs from the
Parliament will create any defect or harm to the Parliament.
This is
not the first time that an opposition party or any other MP has resigned from
Parliament. BNP got a single majority in the elections on 27 February 1991.
After that, BNP formed the government with the support of Jamaat. Awami League
won 88 seats in that election under the caretaker government of Justice
Sahabuddin Ahmed. Awami
League started a movement demanding a non-partisan neutral caretaker government
to protest massive rigging in Magura and Mirpur by-elections. At one stage of
this movement, all members of Awami League decided to resign from Parliament.
On November 8, 1994, Awami League members of parliament submitted their written
resignations to opposition leader Sheikh Hasina. The resignation letters were then
sent to the Speaker on December 24. But the Speaker hesitated to accept this
resignation letter and according to the constitution of Bangladesh, parliament
is sovereign. But BNP took the matter to the High Court. Some of the cadres
loyal to BNP were appointed as judges in the Supreme Court. (BNP has made party
cadres judges every time it came to power) Justice Manwar Uddin was one of
them. On December 11, 1994, Justice Manwar gave an unprecedented judgment where
boycotting the parliament was declared illegal. The High Court ordered the
opposition members to join the parliament. This was a clear interference on the
sovereignty of the National Parliament. This strategy was adopted by the then
BNP government to prevent the opposition from resigning. Because if one-third
of the members resign from the national parliament, the parliament becomes pointless
and election in so many constituencies was not very realistic. This time,
however, such a situation did not arise. Speaker Shirin Sharmin Chaudhury
decided the resignation of six opposition members with great discretion. The
decision was made quickly, which made the difference between Awami League and
BNP clear. In 1994, BNP resorted to various tactics to prevent the resignation
of opposition MPs. They even used the High Court. On the other hand, the Awami
League followed the law unabashedly. So the question is - What was the benefit
of BNP’s movement by resigning these six people who were unimportant in the
parliament, could bring any light and took various facilities including
duty-free cars? BNP has also done this for others. The resignation of BNP MPs
will not accelerate their movement. But this resignation will give some impetus
to the depoliticization process. Our liberals can say that there is no strong
opposition party like BNP in Parliament. On their advice, diplomats from
different countries will say that the national parliament is not inclusive. So,
this untimely resignation drama is only to create the background of another
one-eleven?
The
movement of BNP is at the behest of someone else can be understood from the 10
point demands of BNP declared on 10 December. BNP's main demand is that the
next elections be held under a non-partisan caretaker government. The first
three demands out of 10 points are election-related only. Among these, 4 to 10
points conflict with the first demand. The first phase states, "The
current unelected illegal National Parliament should be dissolved and the unelected,
undemocratic, looter fascist government should resign." I have two
objections to this claim. First, if the parliament is 'unelected' and
'illegitimate' then how come the BNP MPs stayed there for four years. They
didn't just stay, they took a salaries and enjoyed all the benefits as well. How
did BNP live in the 'unelected' and 'illegitimate' parliament for so long? Second,
when you call the government illegitimate, you have no right in making claims
against it. No one can
ask anything from the 'illegal government'. It is neither morally desirable nor
legally possible. But the BNP has given a long plea to what they call the
'illegitimate government'. They are asking for the release of Begum Zia to a government
which they do not accept. Opposition leaders-activists, all human rights
activists, journalists and clerics who performed their duties with
professionalism, demanded cancellation of sentences. The illegitimate
government has been asked to repeal the Digital Security Act in 10 points. It
has been asked to cancel the government's decision to increase the price of
electricity. The demand of BNP also says that 'the illegal government should
bring the price of goods within the purchasing power of the common people'. In
10 points, the government has also been told to form a commission to identify
corruption in all state sectors including money laundering, banking and
financial sector, electricity and fuel sector and stock market. Rescue of
missing people, establishment of professionalism in administration and justice
department are also on the list. It will take three to five years for any
highly efficient and active government to implement the demands of BNP. The
current government has only one year in this term. So what does BNP want, the
current government should be in charge of running the country for one more term
i.e. fourth consecutive term. So
what does BNP want, the current government should be in charge of running the
country for one more term i.e. the fourth consecutive term? Forming the
government once again, Awami League will release those detained for various
reasons including Begum Zia. Will repeal Digital Security Act, Anti-Terrorism
Act etc. Seven points of BNP's 10-point demand will be implemented. Then a
non-partisan caretaker government will be established and elections will be
held. Is this the meaning of BNP's claim? According
to BNP, if the illegal government does everything, then what will BNP do when
it comes to power? The matter is not so simple. I think, behind the 10 points,
there is the evil power of one-eleven. These 10 points have been formulated
from Civils’ drawing room. If the BNP had only wanted a neutral caretaker
government, their demands would have been different. They could have said that
the constitution should be amended to form a non-partisan government. That government will hold an
election within 90 days. That’s it. But the demands made in Clause 4 to 10
apply to a political government and not to an interim government. So the
question arises again. What does BNP really want? Awami League President Sheikh
Hasina gave the idea of a caretaker government. She paved the way for free,
fair and impartial elections during the anti-Ershad movement. Sheikh Hasina's
caretaker system was an emergency system. The main spirit of the 90’s caretaker
government was to stop the undemocratic practice of taking power in violation
of the constitution and bring the country back to democratic flow. Some of its
specific features are noteworthy. This government is for a maximum period of 90
days and the only job of this government is to conduct a fair election. One of
the conditions of the caretaker government was that they could not take any
policy decisions. Responsibilities should be limited to routine work. But in
2001, the caretaker government led by Justice Latifur Rahman took
responsibility and started the first transgression. BNP-Jamaat alliance came to
power in 2001 and tried to undermine the caretaker government system. It was at
this time that the system of 'caretaker government' actually died. This system
proved to be flawed and ineffective for free, fair and impartial elections. The
government that was formed under the leadership of Dr Fakhruddin Ahmed on
January 11, 2007 is by no means a caretaker government. That government had
struck the very spirit of the Constitution. This was basically the cue of the
Civilians with some western help. Where the civilized possessed infinite power
unaccountable for eternity. In the name of reforms, the main aim was to
eliminate politics. The process of depoliticization was implemented in the name
of political reform. Civilian government recklessly arrested politicians. After
the arrest, all those false accusations were circulated in the media and the
mission to make the politicians criminals before the trial was carried out
skillfully. The second target of the eleventh government was businessmen and
industrialists. The civil society embarked on the mission of destroying the
country's economy by targeting them. Harassment of traders, illegal extortion
from various business establishments started. Many businessmen went abroad
after closing their business to protect their honor. Many were humiliated in
the country. In two years, hundreds of crores of money were illegally collected
from business establishments. After the departure of one-eleventh government the
High Court declared this money illegal. This money has been ordered to be
returned but has not been implemented till date. One-eleven governments
indulged in the game of destroying the private sector. As a result, the
backbone of the country's economy was practically broken. Moin U Ahmed and Dr.
Fakhruddin Sarkar embarked on a mission to destroy educational institutions. The
people of this country witnessed the brutality of the riots in Dhaka
University, the brutality of university teachers being taken away with ropes
tied around their waists. Barriers are created in all areas of agriculture,
small and medium industries. One-eleven was a regime of anarchy. Except for a few
civilized and those in power, no one was better. A few western countries and a
small section of civil society plunged the country into deep darkness in the
name of reform. Does
the BNP want such a regime in the country again? At least it seems so from the
10th point demands of BNP. 10 point is actually a reform proposal of one-eleven.
These 10 points are a modified version of what reformist politicians and civil
servants used to say at that time. Just like old wine in new bottles. This 10
point is again creating a way for the evils of one-eleven to come to power. Let’s
assume that a neutral government is formed in the country as per the demand of
BNP. This unelected government will come and say look politicians have made
these demands. So first the garbage must be removed. It will take time.
Civilians will say, repeal the Digital Security Act, investigate the
disappearance, list of money launderers etc. The game of reform will start
again. An incompetent government without elections will run the country for
years. The character of politicians will continue to be damaged. Businessmen will
be blackmailed, harassed. State extortion will bring business to a standstill.
And all the arrangements of BNP is to put such a government in power? It is
noteworthy that some of the civil society of the country are now BNP bigger
than BNP. Some influential media of the country are now giving huge
encouragement to BNP. The interest of some western countries is exactly the
same as in 2007. Those evil forces have come together again. By fielding BNP,
they want to create a background for another unelected chapter. The caretaker
government died in 2007 and the civilians got a taste of absolute power in 2007.
If they get power now, will they hold elections within 90 days? Will they limit
themselves to routine work? The organizational situation of BNP is very
fragile. They have no one to lead the government. For this, the party has
stepped into the trap of civil and westerners. Because, the way BNP is inciting violence now, it is
clear that they do not want free, fair elections, they want to bring a
one-eleven. But Bangladesh will not enter that dark tunnel again. Not at all.
প্রধান সম্পাদকঃ সৈয়দ বোরহান কবীর
ক্রিয়েটিভ মিডিয়া লিমিটেডের অঙ্গ প্রতিষ্ঠান
বার্তা এবং বাণিজ্যিক কার্যালয়ঃ ২/৩ , ব্লক - ডি , লালমাটিয়া , ঢাকা -১২০৭
নিবন্ধিত ঠিকানাঃ বাড়ি# ৪৩ (লেভেল-৫) , রোড#১৬ নতুন (পুরাতন ২৭) , ধানমন্ডি , ঢাকা- ১২০৯
ফোনঃ +৮৮-০২৯১২৩৬৭৭